18 For Christ also died for sins once for all, the just for the unjust, so that He might bring us to God, having been put to death in the flesh, but made alive in the spirit; 19 in which also He went and made proclamation to the spirits now in prison, 20 who once were disobedient, when the patience of God kept waiting in the days of Noah, during the construction of the ark, in which a few, that is, eight persons, were brought safely through the water.
Christ died to demolish sin; all sin. He lived a perfect life and thus, He was perfectly justified in the sight of God. And yet, He sacrificed that perfect life for all of us sinners. He did it because He loves us and God wanted to bring us back to Himself. He had to die to pay for sin, and so His body was destroyed. His spirit however is eternal, just like each of our spirits. This is where this passage gets a little hard to parse. Verse 19 and 20 in particular are hard to interpret but let's see if we can take a stab at it.
One might be tempted to conclude that verse 19 is talking about Christ dying and going to Hell to preach to the spirits in prison. This interpretation however is contrary to the rest of scripture. This verse and a few others have been misinterpreted even by very respected sources. The line, "He descended into hell" even appears in the Apostles Creed, but I still insist that that is inaccurate. (I am not going to spend this post going into all the reasoning behind my argument, as I could spend hours and hours writing a paper on the topic, and that is not really the purpose of this blog.) For one thing, Peter mentioning Christ going to Hell seems way off topic and a needless, confusing aside that would detract from his main point here, and so I don't think that is what he is saying at all. Furthermore, there would be several reasons why Christ preaching in Hell would be fruitless.
The first is that if He did preach in Hell to those already in prison, He would basically be just rubbing their eternal damnation in their faces since they are already in Hell and missed their chance to avoid it. That does not sound like something Jesus would do- It would serve no righteous purpose.
Secondly, from all the study I have done of scripture, it is my firm belief that there is no one currently in Hell... yet. Hell is very real, and was created for Satan and his demons as the ultimate punishment- eternal separation from the presence of God. But Satan is not down in Hell right now, He is active on the Earth. It is Satan's goal to take as many of us with him as possible.
Peter speaks of it later in Chapter 5. But one day, Satan and all those who reject God will be cast into the lake of fire (Hell) after the final judgement of God spoken of in
Revelation 20. But what about all the verses that talk about people dying and going to hell now? If you look at the original language, you will see that the word for hell (lake of fire) is not used, the word "Hades" (grk) or "Sheol" (heb) are used for both righteous and wicked people, and it just means, "out of sight, the place of the dead." This place of the dead is described in
Luke 16, and existed as a holding place for both the damned and the faithful- the damned because none are in hell until judgement, and the faithful because they cannot enter the presence of God until sin is paid for by Christ.
Thirdly, Jesus tells us with His own mouth where He went when He died. This can be found in Jesus' reply to the believing thief on the cross,
"Today, you will be with Me in paradise." That word paradise literally means "garden," but figuratively refers to a place like the garden of eden before the fall, untouched by sin, and is referenced two other times in Scripture. Once in
Revelation, speaking of where the Tree of Life is. And once in
2 Corinthians, as the place Paul was caught up to but allowed to return from, as long as He did not speak of it. This cannot be Hell, whether or not it is Heaven or not i'm not sure. I think it could be Abraham's bosom, as described in Luke 16, or it could be heaven since with Christ's death, sin was also put to death, so then the faithful would be justified and allowed into the presence of God, but again, that might not happen until final judgement either. So "paradise" may just refer to the side of Sheol where the righteous go, where Lazarus was.
So now that we've talked at length about what Peter does not mean, let's talk about what he does mean. We need to think about how this fits into the chapter we just read. He was just talking about the attitude we are to have towards others, how we are supposed to have a strong quiet patience in the face of unbelief. Think of his command to wives, and how they are to behave with their unbelieving husbands. I think he is drawing a parallel back to Noah and how people did not believe him and yet he persevered and was justified by God when the flood came. Noah preached to the world around him that if they did not change their evil ways they would be destroyed and they continued to do whatever they wanted to, yet he continued to be faithful and build the ark and preach until the day it began to rain. Peter is a jew, and he is writing mainly to jews that acknowledge Christ as Lord, so he frequently draws parallels to prominent Old Testament figures. Here is my best paraphrase of verses 19 and 20 above - I also simplified verse 18 to keep the context:
18 Jesus died for sins so that He might bring us to God, His body was put to death, but He continued to live in the Spirit. 19 In the same way, alive in the spirit, He (who is eternal and existed from the beginning before He ever took on a body) preached to the sinners in the days of before the flood through Noah (those who are now dead and in prison.) 20 Those who were disobedient are now dead, even though God was very patient, giving them 120 years of Grace from when Noah began to build the ark and preach until the great flood, but only 8 people were brought to safety through the flood in the ark.
Peter is talking about how Christ was speaking through Noah. It makes sense to me in context because He has already made reference to
Christ speaking through people in the old testament back in 1 Peter 1. It also makes sense to me that Peter would bring attention to God's patience in giving man 120 years to get their act together. In Genesis, God decides that the people of the earth have gotten so bad that they need to be destroyed and He can only find one family, Noah's, that live righteously. Stay with me- Many years before that, a man named Methuselah is born, and God prophesied this coming flood through Him. Not through his mouth, but through His name. The name Methuselah means. "His death shall bring judgement." You may recognize that name, because Methuselah is the oldest recorded person to ever live according to the Bible;
he lived for 969 years. And,
the year He died was the year of the Great Flood. God displays his mercy by prolonging Methuselah's life longer than any other man lived to hold off judgement as long as possible to give people time to repent! God's patience and grace is what we should model to those around us, even those who disagree with us or even hurt us.
This passage is one of the more difficult that I have ever had to dig in but I really seek to understand what is being communicated in a given passage and not just what It appears to say on the surface. You may disagree with me, and that's fine, but I think this interpretation is the most consistent with the rest of scripture as far as I can tell. For more on this, I recommend
this succinct article by Pastor John Piper. Thanks for reading!